Resist Now Resist Now Built for Action Take Action

Indiana Cut Medicaid for Paperwork, Not Ineligibility. $300M Claimed as Savings.

Resist Now 3 min read
Write or Call Your Rep

Indiana Closed Medicaid Cases for Paperwork 4 Times More Than for Ineligibility

Indiana’s Medicaid renewal process is removing far more people for paperwork failures than for actual ineligibility. Data from the Indiana Family and Social Services Administration (FSSA) shows that between March 2025 and June 2026, 31.9% of reviewed cases were closed for noncompliance, while only 7.7% were closed after a finding of ineligibility.

31.9% vs. 7.7% Share of Indiana Medicaid cases closed for noncompliance versus actual ineligibility, March 2025 to June 2026, Indiana FSSA

That ratio means the state is ending coverage for paperwork problems at more than four times the rate it ends coverage because someone no longer qualifies. Many of those removed for noncompliance regain benefits weeks or months later, once they resolve the documentation issue.

The Churn Costs Everyone, Not Just Enrollees

This cycle, called churn, carries real costs on both sides. For enrollees, gaps in coverage mean missed doctor appointments, interrupted prescriptions, and backsliding on chronic conditions while they wait to be reinstated. Hospitals absorb the overflow, as uninsured Hoosiers, including those temporarily removed from Medicaid, turn to emergency rooms for care they cannot otherwise access.

For the state, churn means administrative hours and salaries spent processing the same cases multiple times. Indiana’s FSSA announced on August 6, 2026 that it had returned $300 million in Medicaid cost savings to the General Fund. State officials described the savings as evidence of tightening eligibility rules to protect the program. But the enrollment data shows a substantial share of those departures were procedural, not substantive.

470,000 Hoosiers Face Work Requirements Starting 2027

The administrative burden is set to increase. Up to 470,000 Hoosiers enrolled in the Healthy Indiana Plan will be required to document work or education activity starting in 2027. The Healthy Indiana Plan is the state’s Medicaid expansion program for low-income adults.

Indiana tried a similar modernization in 2009, contracting with IBM to automate case management and reduce in-person meetings. That program failed. Incomplete applications and delayed benefits forced the state to cancel the contract. The same structural problem, a gap between administrative process and actual human capacity to navigate it, appears to be repeating.

Only 44.5% of cases reviewed in the 15-month period were successfully renewed. That means fewer than half of the people whose cases came up for review kept their coverage without interruption.

What You Can Do Now

  1. Call your Indiana state legislators at (317) 232-9400 and tell them to require FSSA to report monthly churn data publicly, including how many people regain Medicaid within 90 days of termination. The 2027 work requirement rollout makes this accountability urgent now.

  2. Contact FSSA directly at 1-800-403-0864 and ask what the agency’s plan is to prevent a repeat of the IBM contract failure when work requirements launch in 2027 for Healthy Indiana Plan enrollees.

  3. If you or someone you know lost Indiana Medicaid coverage, contact Indiana Legal Services at (317) 631-9410. They provide free legal help with Medicaid appeals and can help resolve documentation disputes before deadlines pass.

  4. Submit public comment to FSSA when the agency opens rulemaking on Healthy Indiana Plan work requirements. Watch for notice postings at in.gov/fssa and submit comments naming the 31.9% noncompliance closure rate as evidence that the system needs process improvements before adding new requirements.

Sources

Write Your Rep ↓